Think Title Insurance Is a Waste of Money?
Think Again!
By Jason Kane, Esq.
When buying a home through normal real estate procedures, mortgage lenders
usually require that you purchase homeowner's insurance to protect your home
(and the bank's asset) against fire, theft, and wind damage. If you live near a
body of water or in a flood zone, your lender may require flood insurance, too.
Although required by lenders, homeowners insurance makes good sense since your
home is usually your most important asset. Losing your home is a catastrophic
event - one that many of us don't even want to contemplate.
As a real estate investor, you also want to protect your investment: whether
you're buying a distressed property in order to "flip" it or are purchasing a
property you'll then rent out, you need insurance to protect your asset.
During my career of performing thousands of real estate closings some of the
worst advice I've ever heard given is not to buy title insurance. Some say a
thorough title search is all that's needed. Others think title insurance is one
of those overpriced "nice to have" options foisted on consumers by hungry
insurance agencies. And, some investors mistakenly think that title insurance
can't be purchased for foreclosed properties - which isn't true at all.
Foregoing title insurance when buying your home is a risky choice - a risk
that's significantly compounded when it comes to buying foreclosed properties.
What is title insurance?
Like other insurances, buying an owner's policy of title insurance is a form of
protection against catastrophic events. Title insurance differs from fire or
flood insurance in two ways:
Flood or fire insurance protects you going forward from the day you purchase the
policy. Title insurance, on the other hand, protects you from the day you take
title on the property against any losses arising from events that occurred prior
to the date of the policy. In other words, your coverage ends on the day you
purchase the title insurance policy and extends backward in time.
Unlike other insurances where you make quarterly, semi-annual, or annual
payments for the life of the policy, title insurance is a one-time investment.
You pay for it when closing on the property - and then forget about it until you
need it.
Just as homeowners insurance protects your home against catastrophic loss going
forward, title insurance protects your investment against loss in the form of
undisclosed liens, lawful claims on the property, and fraud that may have
occurred prior to you owning the property - and that didn't show up in a title
search.
Why investors should seriously consider title insurance
"But can I purchase title insurance on a foreclosed property?" you may be
asking. The answer is yes, in some cases you can. Unfortunately, you cannot
purchase title insurance for properties bought at auction (which is one reason
why buying at auction is incredibly risky). However, title insurance is
available when buying foreclosed properties directly from the seller, a real
estate agent acting on the seller's behalf, or the bank.
With regards to title, investing in bank-owned properties (REOs) is less risky
than buying at auction or from the seller because the bank, in an effort to
recoup its losses, will bid on the property at auction, wipe out other lien
holders, then pay the balance of outstanding property taxes to secure the
property's clear title.
Having absorbed these costs, the bank generally adds them to the asking price
and will sell the property with clear title. And, buying REO properties means
you have the opportunity to purchase title insurance.
Why do I recommend investors purchase title insurance when available for
foreclosed properties?
Title insurance protects you from undisclosed liens.
One of the biggest risks that investors run into is finding out the equity they
thought they had when buying a property in foreclosure no longer exists due to
liens being discovered once the property is purchased.
A title search by a competent company will reveal if the party foreclosing on
the property is a first lien holder or a subordinate lien holder. If the
mortgage being foreclosed on is a first mortgage and the property is bought at a
foreclosure sale, then most other liens on the title could be wiped out.
Exceptions to this action include unpaid municipal taxes, IRS tax liens, and in
some instances condominium association fees.
When conducting a title search, you or your real estate attorney will want to
review the title report, check with the municipality prior to bidding on the
property to see if all taxes are paid to date. If the property is a condominium,
call the condo association to determine if fees are due.
In addition to first and second mortgages, other liens include state and federal
tax liens, child support liens, liens from credit card companies, unpaid
contractors, executions, and a host of other individuals and companies. These
types of liens will generally show up in a thorough title search.
Once you purchase the property, you are responsible for any and all liens on the
property - known and not known. Hence, a property you bought at a foreclosure
sale for $150K that has a fair market value of $175K can have $45K in
undisclosed liens - quickly wiping out your profit and your bank account if you
don't own title insurance.
Title insurance protects you from fraud.
Fraud is a major issue in the real estate industry. With title insurance, your
investment is protected 100% should you learn the property was sold to you via
fraudulent methods.
For example, an unscrupulous Seller with a $100,000 second mortgage may want to
"hide" this mortgage to make the foreclosed property appear more desirable to
potential bidders. To do so, all the Seller has to do is go to the local
Registry of Deeds where the property is located and file a mortgage discharge
form. Basically he would forge the signature of his current Lender on a document
that proclaims to state that the second mortgage has been paid off. When you or
your real estate attorney then conduct a title search, you have no reason to
believe a second mortgage exists because it's been discharged.
Or, let's say an elderly woman ends up in a nursing home and can no longer
conduct her own financial affairs. Her son, acting as her agent without her
knowledge, forges her name on the real estate documents and sells the foreclosed
property to you. A few months down the road, the sheriff comes knocking at your
door saying, "You were sold this house under fraudulent pretenses. It doesn't
belong to you." Gulp.
Title insurance reimburses you for the amount of your loss.
Whether you learn title to your property is fraudulent or someone later lays
claim to your property, title insurance ensures you're reimbursed for the amount
of your loss and for your legal and/or attorney fees.
Investors buying distressed properties will also want to consider adding a
special rider to title insurance policies that takes into account inflation.
Let's say you purchase a property for $100K and due to inflation and other
factors, it's now worth $150K. However, due to a fraudulent situation, a former
owner lays claim to your property. The special rider protects your asset at its
current value - $150K - versus its purchase price.
A sound investment that protects your assets
The hypothetical situations listed above are just a few of the innumerable ways
you could find yourself in serious jeopardy of losing your investment - and the
shirt off your back - because of a title defect. (Trust me, I can come up with
dozens more.) Title insurance is an invaluable, inexpensive, one-time investment
that provides you with peace of mind the entire time you own the property.
Don't let title insurance be a spur of the moment decision when closing on a
property. Do your homework: in Massachusetts it pays to shop around for real
estate attorneys whose only specialty is title searches, closings, and insurance
products as they can offer you the best expertise and options.
Title insurance costs do vary but in general, expect to pay roughly $3.50 per
$1,000 of purchase price. For a $300K property, that's a $1,000 policy - a sound
investment no matter how you slice it.
Jason Kane is a real estate attorney and president of Kane Title Services, a
title company located in Plainville, MA that offers title examinations, title
insurance products, and title closings. He can be reached at jkane@kanetitle.com
or at 508-809-6580.
Articles that appear on our website are for information purposes
only. The nature of this information in all of our articles is intended to
provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter
covered. It is posted with the understanding that Mobile Settlement Services,
Inc. is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, or other professional
services. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services
of a competent professional person should be sought. Mobile Settlement Services,
Inc. has taken reasonable care in sourcing and presenting the information
contained on this site, but accepts no responsibility for any financial or other
loss or damage that may result from its use.
Timeliness: Note that most articles published on our website remain on our
website in perpetuity. Only those articles that have been published within the
most recent months may be considered timely. We do not remove articles
regardless of the date of publication, as many, but not all, of our earlier
articles may still have important relevance to some of our visitors. Use
appropriate caution in acting on the information of any article.
Legality: We are a website and title insurance company, we are not a law firm
and we do not offer legal advice nor do we guarantee the legality, worth, or the
accuracy of the content of any article which appears on our website. The
verification of all information and its legal bearing is the sole responsibility
of the visitor.
